Skip to main content

Graph Theory: Independent sets and My blog feactured in feedSpost!!!

Continuing from the previous post ( which is here ). This is a bit short post. I think this short post is not at all helpful in olys but then let's do it cause I find them interesting :P. Here are my notes..


Book referred: Daniel A Marcus Graph theory

Chapter I:

Independence Sets:

  • Independent vertex set: An independent vertex set in a graph is a set of vertices that does not include any adjacent vertices.

  • Independent edge set: An independent edge set in a graph is a set of edges that does not include any edges that share an endpoint.

  • Maximal Independent sets: Largest set possible.

  • $\alpha =$ the number of vertices in a maximal independent set
  • $\alpha ' =$ the number of edges in a maximal independent edge set
Theorem1: In a graph with $n$ vertices and $e$ edges,
a) $\alpha'$ is less than $n/2$
b) if $d_1,d_2,\dots $ be the degress in a maximal independent vertex set, then the sum $d_1+d_2+\dots $ is less than $e.$

Proof: Note that every edge will have distinct vertex endpoints and no two edge share the same. So $|\alpha'|\le n/2.$ 

Let $\{v_1,v_2,\dots, v_{\alpha}\}$ denote the maximal independent set. Note that there is no $a$ in the set such that $v_i$ and $a$ are connected.
Now, note that sum of degrees is always $2e$ where $2$ is there cause each edge give $2$ to the sum. But since  there is no edge, we get $d_1+d_2+\dots \le e$

Corollary: In any $d-$ regular graph with $n$ vertices and $d\ge 1,$ $\alpha $ is less than or equal to  $n/2.$

Proof: Note that the number of edges is $n\cdot d$ and we know that $$d_1+d_2+\dots +d_{\alpha} \le e=\frac{ dn}{2}\text{ but each have degree } d \implies \alpha \le \frac{n}{2}.$$ 

Theorem2: In any graph with $n$ vertices, $\alpha +\alpha'$ is always less than or equal to $n.$

Proof: Let $S$ be a maximal independent vertex set and let $S'$ be the maximal independent edge set. 
Note that $S$ contains $\alpha$ vertices and the $S'$ will have $\alpha'$ vertices. 

So the vertices in $S'$ are $2\alpha.$ But for atleast $\alpha$ vertices are not in $S.$

Hence $\alpha+\alpha'\le n$

A nice question would be is "when is the equality"? Turns out our favourite Bipartite graphs satisfy!

Theorem3: For bipartite graph with $n$ vertices, $\alpha+\alpha'=n$

The proof is beyond my knowledge :pleading:

Corollary: In any $d$ regular bipartite graph with $n$ vertices and $d\ge 1,\alpha=\alpha'=n/2.$

Proof: We know that $\alpha' \le \frac{n}{2}$ and $$d_1+d_2+\dots +d_{\alpha}\le \frac{nd}{2}\implies \alpha\le \frac{n}{2}$$ 

Hence $$\alpha=\alpha'=n/2.$$

Coversing Sets: 

  • Covering vertex set: A covering vertex set in a graph is a set of edges such that any edge has atleast one endpoint.

  • Covering edge set: A covering edge set in a graph is a set of edges such that any vertex is endpoint of atleast one edge.

  • Minimal Covering sets: smallest set possible.

  • $\beta  =$ the number of vertices in a minimal vertex set
  • $\beta ' =$ the number of edges in a minimal vertex edge set

Now, a very curious guess would be if $\alpha+\beta =n?$ Which is true by the collorary!

Theorem1: In any graph $G$, let $S$ be a maximal independent vertex set. Then a minimal covering vertex set can be obtained by taking all vertices are not in $S.$


Proof: Let $S=\{v_1,v_2\dots, v_{\alpha}\}$ be the maximal independent vertex set. Consider the complement of $S=\{a_1,a_2,\dots,a_n\}$ ( say $S^c$) we get that for every $e\in V$ we get that $e $  has atleast one endpoint in $S^c$ ( because $S$ is independent ). Hence $S^c$ is a covering set.

Now, to show the minimality, consider the minimal covering set $X.$ We are assuming ( for contradiction) that $|X|\le |S^c|.$ Then, consider the complement of $X.$ The complement will also be an independent set. But the independent set's cardinality is $>|S|.$ Contradiction.

Hence a minimal covering vertex set can be obtained by taking all vertices are not in $S.$


Corollary: In any graph with $n$ vertices, $\alpha+\beta =n$

Next theorem was very hard to prove and the idea was very non trivial.

Theorem2: In any graph with minimum degree $\delta\ge 1,$ let $S'$ be a maximal independent edge set. Then a minimal covering edge set can be obtained in the following way: Start by including all the edges in $S'.$ Then, for each vertex that is not covered by $S',$ select any one edge at that vertex and include that edge.

Proof: We know that the set is a covering edge set ( say $C$) as every vertex is being include. We start with the claim.

Claim: $C$ has $n-\alpha'$ edges.
Proof: It's just $\alpha' +(n-2\alpha')$ where the second term follows are the number of vertices which arent included in $S'.$

Let $C'$ be any minimal covering edge set and $H$ the subgraph containg all vertices and the edges from $C'$ only. Then $C'$ is the minimal covering edge set of $H.$ And hence $$|C'|=n-\alpha'(H)\ge n-\alpha'$$ where  $\alpha'(H)$ is maximal independece number.
 
And we are done!

Hence we get $\alpha'+\beta=\alpha'+(n-\alpha') =n.$

Yeah that's it for today's post! Also, my blog is featured in FeedSpot's Top 10 Geometry Blogs and Website!! And it is ranked $4$!! I am so happy and I have literally no words T_T.. Really very grateful to FeedSpot! Also thankyou to everyone who reads the blog! 

Hi Sunaina,

My name is Anuj Agarwal, I'm the Founder of Feedspot.

I would like to personally congratulate you as your blog Sunaina thinks absurd has been selected by our panelist as one of the Top 10 Geometry Blogs on the web.

https://blog.feedspot.com/geometry_blogs/

I personally give you a high-five and want to thank you for your contribution to this world. This is the most comprehensive list of Top 10 Geometry Blogs on the internet and I'm honored to have you as part of this!

We'd be grateful if you can help us spread the word by briefly mentioning about the Top 10 Geometry Blogs list in any of your upcoming post.

Please let me know.

Best,
Anuj




Hopeyou enjoyed the blogpost! 
See you soon
Sunaina 💜




Comments

  1. Woahhh great work!!!! Also congrats for getting a rank 4 for the blog 🤩 🥳🥳

    ReplyDelete
  2. Woah congrats!!Love geo live geo and reap geo(idk if this has any meaning)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My experiences at EGMO, IMOTC and PROMYS experience

Yes, I know. This post should have been posted like 2 months ago. Okay okay, sorry. But yeah, I was just waiting for everything to be over and I was lazy. ( sorry ) You know, the transitioning period from high school to college is very weird. I will join CMI( Chennai Mathematical  Institue) for bsc maths and cs degree. And I am very scared. Like very very scared. No, not about making new friends and all. I don't care about that part because I know a decent amount of CMI people already.  What I am scared of is whether I will be able to handle the coursework and get good grades T_T Anyways, here's my EGMO PDC, EGMO, IMOTC and PROMYS experience. Yes, a lot of stuff. My EGMO experience is a lot and I wrote a lot of details, IMOTC and PROMYS is just a few paras. Oh to those, who don't know me or are reading for the first time. I am Sunaina Pati. I was IND2 at EGMO 2023 which was held in Slovenia. I was also invited to the IMOTC or International Mathematical Olympiad Training Cam

Introduction

  Hey Everyone!! This is my first Blog post. So let me give a brief introduction about myself. I am Sunaina Pati. I love solving Olympiad math problems,  learning crazy astronomical facts , playing hanabi and anti-chess, listening to Kpop , love making diagrams in Geogebra and  teaching other people maths 😊 . I love geometry , number theory and Combinatorics . I am starting this blog to keep myself a bit motivated in doing studies 😎 . Right now, I am planning to write walkthroughs on some of the best problems I tried over the week which can refer for hints 'cause solutions contain some major spoilers and one learns a lot while solving the problem on his own rather than seeing solutions . Also, there will be some reviews about Kpop songs, study techniques, my day to day lifestyles,exam reviews and ofc some non-sense surprises 😂.  I am planning to  try  posting every week on Sundays or Saturdays ( most probably) ! Though there is no guarantee about when I will post , so if you are

How to prepare for RMO?

"Let's wait for this exam to get over".. *Proceeds to wait for 2 whole fricking years!  I always wanted to write a book recommendation list, because I have been asked so many times! But then I was always like "Let's wait for this exam to get over" and so on. Why? You see it's pretty embarrassing to write a "How to prepare for RMO/INMO" post and then proceed to "fail" i.e not qualifying.  Okay okay, you might be thinking, "Sunaina you qualified like in 10th grade itself, you will obviously qualify in 11th and 12th grade." No. It's not that easy. Plus you are talking to a very underconfident girl. I have always underestimated myself. And I think that's the worst thing one can do itself. Am I confident about myself now? Definitely not but I am learning not to self-depreciate myself little by little. Okay, I shall write more about it in the next post describing my experience in 3 different camps and 1 program.  So, I got

INMO Scores and Results

Heya! INMO Results are out! Well, I am now a 3 times IMOTCer :D. Very excited to meet every one of you! My INMO score was exactly 26 with a distribution of 17|0|0|0|0|9, which was a fair grading cause after problem 1, I tried problem 6 next. I was hoping for some partials in problem 4 but didn't get any.  I am so so so excited to meet everyone! Can't believe my olympiad journey is going to end soon..  I thought to continue the improvement table I made last year! ( I would still have to add my EGMO performance and also IMO TST performance too) 2018-2019[ grade 8]:  Cleared PRMO, Cleared RMO[ State rank 4], Wrote INMO 2019-2020[ grade 9]:  Cleared PRMO, Cleared RMO[ State topper], Wrote INMO ( but flopped it) 2020-2021[grade 10]:  Cleared IOQM, Cleared INMO [ Through Girl's Quota] 2021-2022[grade 11]:  Wrote EGMO 2022 TST[ Rank 8], Qualified for IOQM part B directly, Cleared IOQM-B ( i.e INMO) [Through general quota],  2022-2023 [grade 12]:  Wrote EGMO 2023 TST [ Rank 2], Mad

Reflecting on past

INMO Scores are out!! I am now a two times INMO awardee :) I got 16|0|1, so 17 in total! Yes, 16 in P1 T_T. I was thinking I would lose marks because of the way I wrote.  Lemme tell ya'll what happened that day but first I should share a few thoughts I had before the exam. My thoughts Honestly, my preparation for INMO was bad. In fact, I should say I didn't work hard at all. As I have said earlier, I had lost all my hopes for INMO and Olympiads as a whole after EGMO TSTs happened.  Art by Jelena Janic EGMO TSTs i.e European Girl's Mathematical Olympiad Team selection Tests 2022.  Literally my thoughts after EGMO TSTs I feel very ashamed to share but I got 1 mark in my EGMO TSTs. Tests in which I literally gave my whole life. I did so many ISLs ( like SO MANY), I mocked EGMO 2021 TST where my score was 28/42 and I perfected Day 2. 1 mark in the TST just showed my true potential. There are way better people than me in olys. A friend even said to me, "If I wouldn't

Bio is Love..

Adios, everyone! Boards preparation at its peak :(  However, I am not able to study how I used to. Every time I try to study for boards, I just keep thinking much about a topic, stare at the book, jam a song or just start doing procrastination by bookmarking random cute problems in HSO. It's been more than a year I have studied like with a focus on a book. My lappy is being a big distraction tbh. So after INMO score come out, I will just give my lappy for repair and say papa to bring it back home after June 2.  Milk and Mocha I literally am taking 2 days to complete 1 bio chapter, some times even 3. The rate of my "slowness" is probably because I am like every 15 minutes checking discord to see if the INMO scores are out or not. So HBCSE, thank you for keeping me anxious.  Funfact:- we must be grateful that there is an organisation that is conducting these national Olys. There are some countries where no Olys are being conducted. ( Same dialogue which mumma uses, but in p

Geometry ( Finally!!!)

 This is just such an unfair blog.  Like if one goes through this blog, one can notice how dominated  Algebra is!! Like 6 out of 9 blog post is Algebra dominated -_- Where as I am not a fan of Algebra, compared to other genres of Olympiad Math(as of now). And this was just injustice for Synthetic Geo. So this time , go geo!!!!!!!!!!!  These problems are randomly from A Beautiful Journey through Olympiad Geometry.  Also perhaps I will post geo after March, because I am studying combi.  Problem:  Let $ABC$ be an acute triangle where $\angle BAC = 60^{\circ}$. Prove that if the Euler’s line of $\triangle ABC$ intersects $AB$ and $AC$ at $D$ and $E$, respectively, then $\triangle ADE$ is equilateral. Solution:  Since $\angle A=60^{\circ}$ , we get $AH=2R\cos A=R=AO$. So $\angle EHA=\angle DOA.$ Also it's well known that $H$ and $O $ isogonal conjugates.$\angle OAD =\angle EAH.$ By $ASA$ congruence, we get $AE=AD.$ Hence $\triangle ADE$ is equilateral. Problem:  A convex quadrilateral $

Solving Random ISLs And Sharygin Solutions! And INMO happened!!

Some of the ISLs I did before INMO :P  [2005 G3]:  Let $ABCD$ be a parallelogram. A variable line $g$ through the vertex $A$ intersects the rays $BC$ and $DC$ at the points $X$ and $Y$, respectively. Let $K$ and $L$ be the $A$-excenters of the triangles $ABX$ and $ADY$. Show that the angle $\measuredangle KCL$ is independent of the line $g$ Solution: Note that $$\Delta LDK \sim \Delta XBK$$ and $$\Delta ADY\sim \Delta XCY.$$ So we have $$\frac{BK}{DY}=\frac{XK}{LY}$$ and $$\frac{DY}{CY}=\frac{AD}{XC}=\frac{AY}{XY}.$$ Hence $$\frac{BK}{CY}=\frac{AD}{XC}\times \frac{XK}{LY}\implies \frac{BK}{BC}=\frac{CY}{XC}\times \frac{XK}{LY}=\frac{AB}{BC}\times \frac{XK}{LY} $$ $$\frac{AB}{LY}\times \frac{XK}{BK}=\frac{AB}{LY}\times \frac{LY}{DY}=\frac{AB}{DL}$$ $$\implies \Delta CBK\sim \Delta LDK$$ And we are done. We get that $$\angle KCL=360-(\angle ACB+\angle DKC+\angle BCK)=\angle DAB/2 +180-\angle DAB=180-\angle DAB/2$$ Motivation: I took a hint on this. I had other angles but I didn't r

Just spam combo problems cause why not

This post is mainly for Rohan Bhaiya. He gave me/EGMO contestants a lot and lots of problems. Here are solutions to a very few of them.  To Rohan Bhaiya: I just wrote the sketch/proofs here cause why not :P. I did a few more extra problems so yeah.  I sort of sorted the problems into different sub-areas, but it's just better to try all of them! I did try some more combo problems outside this but I tried them in my tablet and worked there itself. So latexing was tough. Algorithms  "Just find the algorithm" they said and they died.  References:  Algorithms Pset by Abhay Bestrapalli Algorithms by Cody Johnson Problem1: Suppose the positive integer $n$ is odd. First Al writes the numbers $1, 2,\dots, 2n$ on the blackboard. Then he picks any two numbers $a, b$ erases them, and writes, instead, $|a - b|$. Prove that an odd number will remain at the end.  Proof: Well, we go $\mod 2$. Note that $$|a-b|\equiv a+b\mod 2\implies \text{ the final number is }1+2+\dots 2n\equiv n(2n+1

IMO 2023 P2

IMO 2023 P2 Well, IMO 2023 Day 1 problems are out and I thought of trying the geometry problem which was P2.  Problem: Let $ABC$ be an acute-angled triangle with $AB < AC$. Let $\Omega$ be the circumcircle of $ABC$. Let $S$ be the midpoint of the arc $CB$ of $\Omega$ containing $A$. The perpendicular from $A$ to $BC$ meets $BS$ at $D$ and meets $\Omega$ again at $E \neq A$. The line through $D$ parallel to $BC$ meets line $BE$ at $L$. Denote the circumcircle of triangle $BDL$ by $\omega$. Let $\omega$ meet $\Omega$ again at $P \neq B$. Prove that the line tangent to $\omega$ at $P$ meets line $BS$ on the internal angle bisector of $\angle BAC$. Well, here's my proof, but I would rather call this my rough work tbh. There are comments in the end! Proof Define $A'$ as the antipode of $A$. And redefine $P=A'D\cap (ABC)$. Define $L=SP\cap (PDB)$.  Claim1: $L-B-E$ collinear Proof: Note that $$\angle SCA=\angle SCB-\angle ACB=90-A/2-C.$$ So $$\angle SPA=90-A/2-C\implies \ang